Comparison of Optical Fibres & Satellites
Communication using Optical Fibres
- Optical fibres can be used to transmit:
- Home (landline) telephone signals
- Internet signals
- Cable television signals
- In phone calls from landline phones:
- Electrical signals are converted to light pulses by an infrared laser that flashes at high speed
- Repeaters boost the signal every 30 km along the fibre
- At the receiving end, the digital signal is converted into sound
Landline Telephone Signal Path
Sound from a landline telephone travels through optical fibres and is boosted every 30 km to the landline of the person listening
- Optical fibres can transmit both visible and infrared signals
- These signals travel at a speed of 2 × 108 m/s
- This is not the same as the speed of light in space
- Optical fibres are installed:
- In cables attached to telephone (or telegraph) poles in the street
- Underground from the service box to the telegraph pole or under the sea
Telegraph Poles
Fibre optic cables can be found in the phone cables attached between the telephone poles and the street
- Optical fibres transmit signals over long distances at high speeds
- The fastest internet available in Wales is called superfast broadband
- It uses optical fibres to transmit internet signals from the telephone exchange to a roadside cabinet in each area and then to homes or businesses
- Slower internet speeds are the continued use of old copper cables to carry the internet signal some, or all the way from the telephone exchange
Installation of Optical Fibres for High-Speed Internet
The speed of your internet depends on whether you have all, part or none of your signal transmitted via fibre optic cable from the telephone exchange
- Optical fibres have many advantages over copper cables:
- They use less energy to transmit the signal
- They need fewer boosters to increase the signal
- There is no interference with nearby cables
- They are difficult to intercept
- Their weight is lower, so they are easier to install
Fibre Optic and Copper Cables
Copper cables are heavier and more difficult to install than fibre optic cables
Communication Using Satellites
- Many types of communication use satellites or a combination of satellites and cables:
- Long-distance landline phone calls
- Mobile phone calls
- TV broadcasts
- Satellites can orbit the Earth in one of two orbits:
- Geosynchronous - at an angle between the equator and the north/south poles
- Geostationary - above the equator
Geosynchronous and Geostationary Orbits
A geostationary orbit is directly above the equator
- Communication involving satellites uses microwaves or radio waves to transmit the signal from Earth to a satellite
- Microwave signals must leave Earth and are reflected back to Earth from the satellite
- So, signals travel twice the height of the satellite in space
- They are not reflected from satellite to satellite
- Microwave signals travel huge distances in space
- This creates a time delay
Sending & Receiving Signals via Satellite
Signals are transmitted to a satellite and then reflected back to Earth meaning they travel twice the distance of the height of the satellite
- Remember the following equations when answering questions on this topic:
The wave equation: wave speed = frequency × wavelength
The speed, distance & time equation:
- Where time can refer to time taken or time delay (s)
Worked example
An optical fibre between Wales and Australia has a length of 16 000 km. Information is sent along this optical fibre with a speed of 1.5 × 108 m/s. A geostationary satellite is at a height of 30 000 km above the Earth.
The speed of light in space is 3 × 108 m/s.
A top-secret message needs to be sent from the Welsh government in Wales to the Australian government in Australia.
Compare the two methods of sending the message.
Answer:
Step 1: List the known quantities
- Optical Fibre
- Distance = length = 16 000 km
- Speed of signal = 1.5 × 108 m/s
- Satellite
- Height above the Earth = 30 000 km
- Speed of signal = 3 × 108 m/s
Step 2: Convert the distances into m
- There are 1000 m in 1 km
Length of cable = 16 000 × 1000 = 1.6 × 107 m
Height above the Earth = 30 000 × 1000 = 3 × 107 m
Step 3: State the equation needed to calculate the time of transmission for both signals
Step 4: Calculate the time for transmission of the signal in the optical fibre
Step 5: Calculate the total distance for transmission of the signal to and from the satellite
total distance = 2 × height of satellite
total distance = 2 × (3 × 107)
total distance = 6 × 107 m
Step 6: Calculate the time for transmission of the signal to and from the satellite
Step 7: Compare the time taken for the transmission of the signal using both methods
- The time delay of the signal in the optical fibre is less than for the satellite
OR - The time delay of the satellite is 1.9 times longer than for the optical fibre
- So, the optical fibre will take less time to transmit the signal
Step 8: Compare other factors involved in sending the signal
- Optical fibres are more secure than satellites
- The error rate of signals transferred in optical fibres is much less than in satellites
Examiner Tip
In your exam, you could be asked to compare with calculations communication via satellite and optical fibre having been given information on them.