The table below shows the physical properties of substances X, Y and Z.
Substance |
Melting point (oC) |
Electrical conductivity when molten |
Solubility in water |
X |
839 |
Good |
Soluble |
Y |
95 |
Very poor |
Almost insoluble |
Z |
1389 |
Good |
Insoluble |
Which one of the following statements about X, Y and Z is completely true?
Statement 1: X has a giant ionic structure, Y has a giant molecular structure, Z is a metal
Statement 2: X is a metal, Y has a simple molecular structure, Z has a giant molecular structure
Statement 3: X is a metal, Y has a simple molecular structure, Z has a giant ionic structure
Statement 4: X has a giant ionic structure, Y has a simple molecular structure, Z is a metal
Answer:
- Compound X has a relatively high melting point, is soluble in water and conducts electricity when molten
- This suggests that X has a giant ionic structure
- Compound Y has a low melting point which suggests that little energy is needed to break the lattice
- This suggests that Y is a simple molecular structure
- This is further supported by its low electrical conductivity and it being almost insoluble in water
- Compound Z has a very high melting point, which is characteristic of either metallic, giant ionic lattices or giant covalent / molecular lattices
- However since it is insoluble in water, compound Z must be a metal
- Therefore, the correct answer is Statement 4