The Merchant's Tale: What To Compare It To (OCR A Level English Literature)
Revision Note
The Merchant’s Prologue and Tale: What To Compare It To
For Component 1 Section 2, you will study one pre-1900 drama text and one pre-1900 poetry text. For Section 2, the set texts have been chosen as they illuminate one another and share connections from across the genres of drama and poetry. From the choice of set texts, we will explore Geoffrey Chaucer’s The Merchant’s Prologue and Tale (from the set list of pre-1900 poetry texts) and John Webster’s The Duchess of Malfi (from the set list of pre-1900 drama texts). Given that The Merchant’s Prologue and Tale and The Duchess of Malfi explore key themes of marriage, gender, morality and individual power, these two texts can be compared effectively. A detailed comparison of these two texts will be explored here, along with a comparative summary of other texts:
Examiner Tip
The second task in Component 1 is a comparative essay, and it should include an integrated comparative analysis of the relationships between texts. This means that you are required to explore contrasts, connections and comparisons between different literary texts, including the ways in which the texts relate both to one another and to literary traditions, movements and genres. The best responses pick up on the prompt words within the quotation given in the task and then select material accordingly. In this way, by sustaining a coherent, question-focused argument throughout, comparison becomes a technique through which the texts can be used to shed light on each other.
For the following suggested comparison, you will find:
The comparison in a nutshell
Similarities between the ideas presented in each text
Differences between the ideas presented in each text
Evidence and analysis of these similarities and differences
Examiner Tip
It is better to consider connections and interpretations of the texts in your essay, rather than list as much evidence from the texts as you know without detailed exploration. If you write a little about a lot of evidence, you will struggle to produce a coherent, detailed and sustained argument.
The Merchant’s Prologue and Tale and The Duchess of Malfi
Comparison in a nutshell:
This comparison provides the opportunity to compare depictions of marriage and, in particular, the way individuals are manipulated or regulated by social constructs and stereotypes. The texts explore the question of female morality and the ability to achieve perfection in flawed societies.
Similarities:
Topic sentence | Both Chaucer and Webster consider the impact of secrecy and revelations, by presenting female characters whose true nature is hidden due to patriarchal standards regarding marriage | |
Evidence and analysis | The Merchant’s Prologue and Tale | The Duchess of Malfi |
The Merchant (on a pilgrimage to Canterbury) tells a story about an affair
| Webster’s protagonist, the Duchess, is duplicitous to her brothers by marrying in secret:
| |
In the tale, the Merchant shows how May presents an image to male characters that reflects their own desires, behaving as a submissive woman in order to manipulate men:
| Webster shows how the Duchess maintains two versions of her identity in order to maintain autonomy:
| |
May’s deceit (an affair outside her contractual marriage) is kept hidden from her husband by a trick played by the god Pluto:
| The Duchess's secret marriage, which defies her strict societal duties, must be hidden from her brothers:
| |
Chaucer shows, through the Merchant, that the imbalanced marriage between May and Januarie continues:
| Webster conveys the futility of the Duchess’ struggle to live according to her desires:
| |
Chaucer’s tale presents the way May defies social expectations by exhibiting her resistance to standards of behaviour for women:
| Similarly, Webster explores patriarchal control regarding marriage by presenting Ferdinand’s outrage at his sister’s secret marriage:
| |
Both female characters highlight the way gender stereotypes and imbalanced marital constructs can result in repressed desire that manifests in socially unacceptable acts |
Topic sentence | Both Chaucer and Webster explore hypocrisies within social constructs, which result in oppressive, controlling and yet internally blind leaders | |
Evidence and analysis | The Merchant’s Prologue and Tale | The Duchess of Malfi |
Januarie, the male character of the Merchant’s tale, is a “Knyght” who holds a position of power:
| The Duchess's brothers, Duke Ferdinand and the Cardinal, represent powerful leaders:
| |
Januarie, an older man, marries May, a much younger woman:
| The brothers are shown to be demeaning in their attitude to the Duchess and women:
| |
Januarie makes clear his attraction to May is due to her youthful beauty:
| Ferdinand’s reasons for not wanting the Duchess to remarry are presented as superficial:
| |
Throughout the poem, the heroic and virile image of the “Knyght” is exposed as superficial
| The Cardinal is exposed as hypocritical:
| |
Although Januarie is physically turned “blynd” by Pluto, which makes him increase his control over May, this is when he loses her to Damian. Januarie begins to realise his flaws, noting that he is “jalos”:
| Ferdinand’s diseased mind shows some sense of remorse for his actions towards the Duchess before he dies:
| |
Both texts explore the male stereotype through the lens of prideful superiority, presenting flaws which, if not understood, leave the characters paranoid |
Differences:
Topic sentence | While both Chaucer and Webster present characters who defy the system and are shamed for their misdeeds, Chaucer leaves his ending ambiguous, while Webster presents clear punishments for his heroes in the resolution | |
Evidence and analysis | The Merchant’s Prologue and Tale | The Duchess of Malfi |
While the poem is satirical, it can be considered a warning or a fable in its comparison to a folk tale, leaving readers with an ambiguous ending | The Duchess of Malfi can be considered a political satire as it exposes violent abuse within established social constructs and shows the attempts of those who battle under its restraints as futile | |
In The Merchant’s Tale, the unhappy and deceitful marriage between Januarie and May continues:
| Whereas, The Duchess of Malfi ends with the deaths of Antonio and the Duchess:
| |
The Merchant’s Tale seems to end with a confirmation that imbalanced marriage is inevitable:
| The play’s ending suggests that marriage that defies societal standards and codes of conduct within Renaissance nobility cannot survive:
| |
While Chaucer’s fable, told by a merchant as an allegory about marital tensions, ends with the continuation of an unhappy marriage, perhaps as a warning to men to avoid imbalanced marriages or to present the inevitability of unhappy marriage, Webster’s satirical play ends pessimistically with death and tragedy |
Topic sentence | While Chaucer satirises courtly love in a Romantic mediaeval England, Webster mocks hypocrisies within a patriarchal Italian Renaissance court | |
Evidence and analysis | The Merchant’s Prologue and Tale | The Duchess of Malfi |
Chaucer’s poem uses a fantastical and romantic setting, drawing on comparisons with the Garden of Eden | Webster’s setting, an Italian court, highlights themes of corruption within religious institutions and the political sphere | |
In The Merchant’s Tale, May goes to a garden (which perhaps alludes to the Garden of Eden) inhabited by the gods Pluto and Prosepina | The Duchess is forced to leave her Amalfi home, is banished from Ancona and is imprisoned in Duke Ferdinand’s palace | |
May’s sexual encounters with Damian by a pear tree (which may symbolise the Tree of Knowledge) are vividly presented:
| Webster shows intimate scenes between the Duchess and Antonio in her room, suggesting she has freedom in her own territory:
| |
Chaucer’s comedic fable explores marriage as an inevitable and relentless problem, while Webster’s dark revenge tragedy explores corruption and violence |
Comparisons with other texts
The following list is not exhaustive, and the wider you read, the more connections and comparisons you will have to draw upon in the exam. Some of the following examples are taken from the prescribed text list, while others are suggestions for comparison.
Text | Summary | Key comparisons with The Merchant’s Prologue and Tale |
“Edward II” by Christopher Marlowe (1592) – set text list | Edward II is a historical tragеdy that chroniclеs thе turbulеnt rеign of King Edward II of England. Thе play dеlvеs into Edward's controvеrsial rеlationships, particularly with Piеrs Gavеston, which leads to political unrеst and rеbеllion. Edward's pеrsonal dеsirеs clash with political dutiеs, meaning his downfall bеcomеs inеvitablе |
|
“She Stoops to Conquer” by Oliver Goldsmith (1771) – set text list | Shе Stoops to Conquеr is about the misadvеnturеs of a young man namеd Marlow whose romantic еntanglеmеnts lead to chaos |
|
“A Doll’s House” by Henrik Ibsen (1879) – set text list | A Doll’s House portrays Nora, thе protagonist, leaving hеr husband and childrеn to sееk hеr own idеntity, challеnging thе traditional rolеs imposеd by sociеty |
|
“An Ideal Husband” by Oscar Wilde (1895) – set text list | The play revolves around Sir Robert Chiltern, a respected politician, and his seemingly perfect life. However, when a woman named Mrs Cheveley threatens to expose a dark secret from his past, Sir Robert’s integrity and marriage are put to the test |
|
Last updated:
You've read 0 of your 10 free revision notes
Unlock more, it's free!
Did this page help you?