Symmetric vs Asymmetric Encryption (OCR A Level Computer Science)
Revision Note
Written by: Callum Davies
Reviewed by: James Woodhouse
Symmetric & Asymmetric Encryption
What is Encryption?
Encryption is crucial for converting readable data into an unreadable format
Its primary aim is to secure data from unauthorised access, making it a highly important technique for defending against cyber-attacks and data breaches
Encryption methods use 'keys', which are specialised programs designed to scramble or unscramble data
Selecting a type of encryption isn't a daily choice for most people
Modern devices and technologies, e.g. web browsers (HTTPS protocol), provide a basic level of encryption by default
Most people transfer sensitive data without thinking about it because of developments in technology
How does Symmetric Encryption work?
The sender uses a key to encrypt the data before transmission
The receiver uses the same key to decrypt the data
It's usually faster, making it ideal for encrypting large amounts of data
The significant downside is the challenge of securely sharing this key between the sender and receiver
If a bad actor captures the key, they can decrypt all messages intercepted in transmission
Structure of Symmetric Encryption
How does Asymmetric Encryption work?
Asymmetric encryption uses two keys:
a public key for encryption
and a private key for decryption
Receivers openly share their public key
Senders use this public key to encrypt the data
The receiver's private key is the only key that can decrypt the data and is kept locally on their side
The public and private keys are created at the same time and are designed to work together in this way
It is typically slower than symmetric encryption
It is generally used for more secure and smaller data transactions, e.g. passwords, bank details
Structure of Asymmetric Encryption
Choosing an Encryption type
Symmetric encryption is fast but has key-sharing issues; asymmetric is slower but solves these issues.
The choice should be made based on the situation's needs: whether speed or security is more critical.
Encryption Type | Suitable For | Reasons to choose |
|---|---|---|
Symmetric | Large files, databases |
|
Asymmetric | Confidential/secret communications |
|
Worked Example
Discuss the impact of modern encryption on society. You should refer to:
• The importance of asymmetric encryption and how it differs from symmetric encryption.
• Different circumstances in which symmetric and asymmetric encryption may be used.
[9]
How to Answer This Question:
Structuring your answer carefully is the best approach for gaining the most marks for the question. Use the list below as a guide:
Start with an introduction outlining the importance of modern encryption in society. Consider some scenarios where private data is being transferred, such as at school or the workplace.
Discuss the key features of asymmetric encryption, emphasising its significance and how it resolves key distribution issues.
Compare asymmetric and symmetric encryption, pointing out the differences and mentioning the single key used in the latter.
Provide examples of scenarios where symmetric and asymmetric encryption are most suitable, discussing the pros and cons of each.
Conclude by summarising the overall impact of both types of encryption on society, including data security, online transactions, and individual privacy.
Answer:
Example Answer That Gets Full Marks:
Encryption is critical to protect people from data misuse in today's digital society. It's a fundamental aspect of secret communications, e-commerce, and the protection of personal information.
Asymmetric encryption uses a pair of keys: a public key for encryption and a private key for decryption. This solves a crucial issue in key distribution, as the public key can be openly shared without compromising the secure private key. Asymmetric encryption forms the backbone of secure online transactions and communications, enabling features like digital signatures and secure key exchange.
Unlike asymmetric encryption, symmetric encryption uses a single key for both encryption and decryption. While it's usually faster and more efficient for handling large data, it poses a challenge in securely sharing the key between parties. Asymmetric encryption, though generally slower, alleviates this issue by using a public-private key pair, adding an extra layer of security.
Symmetric encryption is ideal for quick scenarios, such as encrypting large files or databases within a secure network where key distribution is not an issue. Asymmetric encryption is preferred in situations demanding high security, like secure email communications or online banking, where a compromise in key distribution can lead to significant risks.
Using symmetric and asymmetric encryption profoundly impacts society, enabling secure data transmission, enhancing online commerce, and protecting individual privacy. However, the consequences of providing individuals with highly secure methods of communication mean that regular users can communicate for nefarious reasons, such as organised crime. For situations where an individual must choose between the two methods, they should consider if the data transfer needs to happen quickly or securely.
Last updated:
You've read 0 of your 5 free revision notes this week
Sign up now. It’s free!
Did this page help you?
